Listen to my latest podcast episode:

Reading Strategies: How to Get Students Thinking About What They Read podcast cover

Reading Strategies: How to Get Students Thinking About What They Read

Click Play to Listen

When we think about the reading strategies we use in our classrooms, we usually think about helping students understand what they read. We teach students to make inferences, identify important ideas, analyze characters, and find evidence in a text. But understanding what they read is only part of what I want for my students. I also want them thinking about what they read.

Those two things can look very different in the classroom.

A student can give me the correct answer to a comprehension question. They may even be able to point to the exact place in the text where they found it. That’s important. But I also want to know what they’re thinking about that information. What are they noticing? What are they beginning to understand? Has anything they’ve read made them think differently?

For me, that’s where reading comprehension becomes more than finding the answer.

The Right Answer Doesn’t Tell Us Everything

There are plenty of times when I need students to find the correct answer. If we’re reading an informational text, I want them to be able to locate important information.  If they are researching information they have to be able to pull out pertinent information.  If we’re reading fiction, there are details about the characters and events that students need to understand before we can go much further.

The right answer matters.

But it doesn’t always tell me everything I want to know about a student’s comprehension.

Think about a question you’ve asked your students recently. Maybe a student answered it correctly, you said, “Exactly,” and then moved on to the next question.

I’ve done that thousands of times.

What I don’t always know is what was happening in that student’s head before they gave me the answer. Did they make a connection between two parts of the text? Did something surprise them? Were they thinking about why a character made that choice? Did they have a completely different idea before something in the text changed their mind?

There may be more thinking there than the answer shows us.  And there may also be times when there isn’t.

That’s why I think it’s worth paying attention to what happens after students find the answer.

Thinking About Reading Is Part of Comprehension

When students read outside of school, no one follows them around with a list of comprehension questions. They have to make sense of what they’re reading on their own.  They think about what they’re reading, react to it, and sometimes change their thinking as they learn more.  That’s part of comprehension too.

I want students to recognize that reading isn’t simply about getting to the end of a text and being able to answer questions about it. Their own thinking is part of the reading process.

That can be a shift for students who have become very focused on whether their answer is right or wrong.

I’ve had plenty of students who give an answer and immediately look at me for confirmation. They aren’t necessarily interested in continuing the thought. They simply want to know: Was I right?

Students Need Opportunities to Keep Thinking

We can’t expect students to automatically become thoughtful readers simply because we’ve taught them reading skills. Like anything else we want students to become more independent with, they need opportunities to practice.

That doesn’t mean every reading question needs to become a long discussion or every text needs an elaborate activity attached to it. What matters is that students regularly have opportunities to do something with what they’ve understood.

Sometimes that means explaining what led them to an idea. Other times it means hearing another reader’s perspective and realizing there is more than one way to interpret something. It might mean having enough time to reconsider an idea instead of immediately moving on to whatever comes next.

The more often students have those opportunities, the more familiar that kind of thinking becomes.

Our Reading Strategies Can Make Room for That Thinking

The good news is that we don’t need to completely change the way we teach reading to make this happen. We can still ask comprehension questions, teach specific reading skills, check for understanding, and make sure students can find evidence in a text. We’re just paying a little more attention to what happens around those things.

Are students always waiting for us to tell them whether they’re right? Do we hear much about what they’re thinking beyond the answer? Are there opportunities for students to develop an idea before we move on? Sometimes the opportunity for deeper thinking is already there. We just have to give students enough room to do something with it.

Giving Students Room to Think

Ultimately, I want my students to leave my classroom knowing that reading is about more than finding information or getting the answer right. I want them to see themselves as readers who have ideas about what they read and are willing to explore those ideas.

We don’t need to turn every question into a bigger conversation. But we can look for those moments when there’s more thinking just beneath the answer and give students a chance to keep going. The more opportunities they have to do that, the more natural it becomes.

Resources you may find helpful:

Keep listening:

Further reading: 

Click to View Transcript

Hello everyone, welcome to the Middle School Cafe podcast!
I hope you had a chance to catch last week’s bonus episode, where I talked about teaching author’s craft by bringing author voices into the classroom. I shared a little about Voices in Lit, a series of podcast lessons created specifically for students where they can hear from authors as they explore the craft behind their writing. If you missed that episode, I’ll link it in today’s show notes so you can go back and listen.
We also just wrapped up our back-to-school series, and I know we have quite a few new listeners joining us, so I thought this would be a good time to introduce myself again. I’m Carolyn Wahl, and I’ve been in education for 31 years. After spending most of those years in the middle school classroom, I now work at the university level with preservice teachers. This is my second year in that role and I absolutely love working with college students and helping them prepare for their own classrooms.
Here on the podcast, I share the strategies, routines, and ideas that I’ve found make a difference with middle school students, especially when it comes to reading. I also create classroom resources that take many of those ideas and turn them into something you can pick up and use with your students.
If you’re new, welcome, I’m so glad you’ve joined us! Let’s get into today’s topic.
Today, I want to talk about something that happens all the time in our classes. Our students can often find the answer we’re looking for, but finding the answer and really thinking about what they’ve read aren’t the same thing.
You know those moments when a student gives you the right answer, but then you ask them to expand or tell you a little more about it—and they can’t?
Maybe you’re talking about a character’s choices or why something happened in the text. The student’s first answer is good. It makes sense. But when you keep the conversation going, you realize they haven’t really thought much beyond that first response.
But getting the answer is only part of what I want students to be able to do as readers. I want them to think about why they came to that answer. I want them to make connections, notice things in the text, and be able to talk about what they’re thinking. And that takes practice.
If most of our questions end as soon as students give us the answer we’re looking for, we’re giving them a lot of practice answering questions. We’re not necessarily giving them the same amount of practice thinking about what they’ve read.
So that’s what I want to talk about today. How do we get students to go beyond finding the answer and really think about what they’re reading?
It makes sense that students focus on the answer. A lot of what we ask them to do with a text has a clear answer, so they get used to reading with that goal in mind.
And students get pretty good at figuring out what we want from them.
We ask a question during a class discussion. A student gives us the answer we were hoping for. We say, “Yes!” or “Exactly!” and move on to the next question. We’re not doing anything wrong. We have lessons to teach and things we need to accomplish. But over time, students can start to get the message that the goal of the conversation is to figure out what answer the teacher is looking for.
But reading isn’t always that straightforward.
There are certainly things we need students to understand about a text. But reading also requires them to think about what they’ve read. Why did a character make that choice? Why did the author include that detail? Those kinds of questions don’t usually have one right answer.
I want students to be able to say, “Here’s what I think,” and then be able to talk about what led them to their response. And as they talk it through, their thinking might grow or even change.
So sometimes that means I just need to stay with their answer a little longer.
I don’t think the follow-up has to be complicated. A simple, “What makes you think that?” or “Tell me more about that,” can give a student the opportunity to go back to the text and think a little more about their response.
But then I have to listen to what they say, because that usually tells me where to go next.
If they give me something really general, I might ask what they noticed in the text that made them think that. If they’re having trouble explaining their answer, I might rephrase the question or connect it back to something we’ve already talked about.
Maybe I ask why a character made a particular choice, and a student tells me, “Because she was angry.” Instead of saying, “Right,” and moving on, I ask, “How do you know she was angry?” That sends them back to the text to think about what the character said or did. Their response gives me a better sense of what they understood and helps me decide where to take the conversation next.
This also means getting comfortable with a little silence. I’ve talked about this in other episodes because I think it’s something we have to remind ourselves of as teachers. We ask a question, there’s silence, and we want to jump in and help. Sometimes students just need a few seconds to think. If I’m asking them to go beyond that first answer, I have to give them time to think through their answers.
The goal isn’t to keep asking questions until they finally figure out the answer I’m looking for. It’s to help them slow down and think about why they responded the way they did.
They don’t always have to work through that thinking with me, either. Giving students opportunities to talk about what they’re reading with each other can push their thinking in a different way.
I did an episode recently about academic conversations and getting students more comfortable talking with their classmates, so I’ll link that one in the show notes. However, what I want to focus on here is what those conversations can do for comprehension.
When I read something on my own, I’m limited to what I notice. I bring my own experiences, my own background knowledge, and my own way of interpreting what I’m reading. Our students do the same thing.
Put two readers together, though, and now each one has access to something they didn’t have before: another perspective – the other person’s thinking.
A student might hear a peer point out a detail they completely passed over. They might hear a different explanation for a character’s behavior and realize it makes sense. They might disagree with what their partner says, but even that disagreement makes them stop and think about why they understood the text differently.
That’s important because comprehension isn’t just remembering what happened. Students are constantly taking what the text gives them and trying to make sense of it. Talking with another reader gives them another perspective to consider as they do that.
It also changes what we’re asking students to do. If I ask a question and they give me an answer, they’re responding to something I’ve already decided is worth thinking about. When they’re talking with another student, they have to listen to an idea they may not have been expecting. They have to decide whether it fits with what they understood. They may have to go back and reconsider something they thought they understood the first time.
I think that’s where these conversations become especially valuable. It’s not really about whether students agree with each other at the end. Sometimes hearing a different idea strengthens what they already thought. Sometimes it changes their thinking. Sometimes it simply helps them notice something they missed.
Any of those can deepen their understanding of what they’re reading.
That’s why, for me, student conversation isn’t just about getting kids talking. I want them hearing how other readers make sense of a text because that gives them another opportunity to think more carefully about how they’re making sense of it themselves.
The more opportunities students have to think about what they’re reading, the more comfortable they become doing it. I want this kind of thinking to become a habit for them. I want them to get used to doing more than just reading the words on the page. I want them thinking about what they’re reading.
That takes practice. Students need opportunities to stop, notice things, make connections, and think about what’s happening in their books.
One of the ways I’ve given students that practice is through reading reflections.
Reading reflections give students a chance to take something they’re reading and think about it a little more deeply. They might make a connection, think about how a conflict is developing, or consider how something they learned changes their understanding of what happened earlier in the story.
What I like about doing this with their independent reading is that every student can practice the thinking with a book they’ve chosen – something they are already interested in. We might be working on characterization or conflict or theme, and they can take that idea back to their own book and think about how it shows up there.
This is actually why I moved away from traditional reading logs. I wasn’t really interested in monitoring how many pages students read or how many minutes they spent reading. And I definitely didn’t want to spend my time policing whether or not a parent signed a reading log. What I really wanted to know was, what are you thinking about what you’re reading?
Reading reflections gave me a much better way to see that and get a better sense of their comprehension. Students were getting regular practice thinking about their books, while I was getting a window into what they were noticing and understanding.
I do have a set of Independent Reading Reflection Journals that I use for this, and I’ll share those with you in the show notes. There are 36 weekly reflections that students can use with whatever book they’re reading, so if you want to give students regular opportunities to practice this kind of thinking without having to come up with a new reflection each week, they’re ready for you to use.
I think the bigger idea here is that I don’t want reading comprehension to become a cycle of read the text, find the answer, move on. Of course I want students to understand what they’re reading, and I want them to be able to find information in a text when they need to.
And yes, sometimes there really is a correct answer. But that’s only part of comprehension.
I also want students noticing, questioning, connecting, interpreting, reconsidering, and talking about what they’re thinking. Those things take practice, and we can give students that practice in lots of different ways.
It might happen when we stay in the conversation a little longer after they give us an answer, or when students compare their thinking with a partner and realize someone else interpreted the text differently.
It can also happen through reading reflections that ask them to stop and think about their own books.
None of this requires us to turn every reading question into something complicated. We simply need to resist the urge to move on so quickly.
So this week, pay attention to what happens after a student gives you the right answer. Not because the right answer doesn’t matter—it does—but because there may be more thinking there if we give them the opportunity to keep going.
Can they tell you what they’re thinking? Can they make a connection or explain what they’re noticing? Can they consider another reader’s idea?
That’s the part I don’t want us to miss. Our goal isn’t just to help students become better at reading words on a page and finding answers in texts. We want them to become readers who think about what they’re reading. And like any reading habit, that kind of thinking develops with practice.
If you’d like to use the Independent Reading Reflection Journals I mentioned earlier to help students build that habit, you’ll find them linked in today’s show notes.
Before I go, I also want to take a minute to say thank you. The Middle School Cafe podcast recently passed 25,000 downloads, which is pretty exciting! I know there are a lot of ELA podcasts you could be listening to, and I really appreciate that you choose to spend some of your time here with me.
If the podcast has given you an idea you’ve tried in your classroom or just made you think about something a little differently, I’d love it if you’d take a minute to leave a rating or review. It helps other ELA teachers find the podcast, and it’s a great way to help this little community continue to grow.
Thank you for being here and for helping us reach 25,000 downloads. I really appreciate you listening, and I’ll see you next time!

Related Podcasts

Cookie Consent Banner by Real Cookie Banner